Asking price is about 5% above the estimated value. Estimates can be off and may not reflect the home's current market value.

5107 Saint Albans AveSarasota, FL 34242

$1,199,000

Est. $1,139,100

  • 2,276 sqft
  • 3 beds
  • 3 baths

About this home

  • Spacious island
  • Quartz countertops
  • Oversized two-car garage
  • Backyard oasis
  • Large master suite
  • Open airy floor plan
  • Canopy road

Welcome to 5107 Saint Albans Avenue – a beautifully reimagined home on one of Siesta Key's most sought-after streets. This exceptional 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom ranch home, plus den, has been meticulously updated and nearly rebuilt with every modern convenience in mind. Situated on a large, tree-canopied lot with a quiet, county-protected street, this property offers both tranquility and privacy, while being within walking or biking distance to the world-famous Siesta Village and Siesta Beach.

As you approach this home, you are welcomed by the lush, established landscaping and canopy road, ensuring both beauty and peacefulness. The interior features an open, airy floor plan with soaring volume ceilings, skylights, and the gleaming restoration of original terrazzo flooring, adding timeless elegance. The home is equipped with new impact-resistant doors and custom-built closets, ensuring both style and security.

The heart of the home is the gourmet kitchen, complete with high-end stainless steel appliances, soft-close cabinetry, quartz countertops, and a spacious island. Perfect for entertaining or family meals, this kitchen seamlessly flows into the living areas, providing a modern and functional layout.

The large master suite offers a private retreat, with an impressive en-suite bath featuring a double vanity, oversized tub, and a separate frameless glass rain shower. The guest bath is equally stunning. All bathrooms are fully updated with top-quality materials and finishes.

Step outside to your backyard oasis, complete with an open-air pool, perfect for year-round relaxation and enjoyment. A brand-new pool pump ensures optimal performance and efficiency. The entire backyard is enclosed by a privacy fence, offering an intimate space for lounging or entertaining guests. The large lot also features a separate side yard, perfect for outdoor activities and recreation, already equipped with multiple climbing and swinging ropes. The oversized two-car garage provides additional storage space, and the brand-new landscaping further enhances the outdoor experience.

This home is packed with energy-efficient features, including a 2024 Tesla Solar system with 2 Powerwalls, a brand-new water heater, and two HVAC systems with three zones, offering exceptional climate control. Battery backup together with solar means the entire house can go “off-grid” indefinitely.

Beyond the home’s impressive features, the location is truly one of a kind. Living here means you can stroll or bike to Siesta Village and Siesta Beach, enjoying the local shops, bistros, and, most importantly, you’ll enjoy easy access to the pier and a quieter, more private beach experience – a world away from the traffic and crowds of the public beach and north and south bridges. This neighborhood offers a lifestyle that many only dream of, with easy access to everything on Siesta Key, without having to jump in your vehicle. Additional features include a transferable low flood insurance policy and proximity to top-rated Phillippi and Brookside schools, which have world-renowned IB programs. Don’t miss your chance to own this meticulously restored and updated gem in one of the most coveted areas of Siesta Key. Schedule your private tour today!

  • 1 day on Realtyless
  • 1 view

Property history

  • Listed for sale

    Nov 16, 2026

    $1,199,000

    $527/sqft
  • Listing removed

    Nov 15, 2026

    $1,199,000

    $527/sqft
  • Price change

    Nov 3, 2026

    $1,199,000

    Down 2.0%$527/sqft

Monthly payment estimate

$8,081/mo

Principal & interest
$6,453
Property tax
$1,269
Home insurance
$360

Down payment · $239,800

Estimate only, using local tax and insurance figures. Your actual payment depends on your lender. Starting rate: Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average, week of Nov 12.

Map showing 5107 Saint Albans Ave Sarasota, FL 34242

Nearby cities

Distances from Sarasota, FL

Deal alerts

Find the best deals

Sign up today and be the first to hear about new deals.

  • Sort homes by best deal
  • Compare asking prices to estimated values
  • Contact owners directly