High Price Based on an estimated value, which may not reflect the home's current market value.

5272 Warrensville RdMontoursville, PA 17754

$309,900

Est. $229,600

  • 1,248 sqft
  • 3 beds
  • 2 baths

About this home

The home is a 1,248 square foot story and a half cape style residence situated on approximately .502 acre lot in Eldred Township, Montoursville Area School District. There is a covered patio on the rear of the home (28'L x 18'W), a detached 2 car garage (36'Lx18'W) with an attached lean-to (22'x27') leading to the back yard pool area. The lot features a beautiful 2 story 30'x40' board and batten barn with a 40'x8' covered porch. The first floor of the barn has two, 12'Wx10'H entry doors with garage door openers installed, with 11' high ceilings on the first floor of the barn. The second story of the barn has engineered hardwood flooring for entertaining/family gatherings, and a ceiling height of 13.6'. The home has been renovated extensively to include: all new stainless KitchenAid appliances installed in the kitchen in 2016, new Amish built kitchen cabinetry installed 2016, 2 new bathrooms 2016, entire home upgraded electrical to 200 amp with new wiring and all plumbing converted to PEX 2016, spray foam insulation to the entire home 2016, new Bryant Legacy Line oil furnace 2016, new on-demand Rinnai tankless hot water heater 2016, new water pressure tank 2016, new well pump 2016, new water filtration system 2016, new roof installed 2016, new windows installed 2017, ADT security system installed 2017, 22kw Generac backup generator installed 2019, above ground pool installed 2017, 30'x40' board and batten barn constructed 2019. All interior walls of the home are 1”x8” poplar shiplap installed in 2016-2017, with the exception of the first- floor bathroom where you will find subway tile. The home has 5 new smoke detectors installed 8/26. Maintenance has been completed on the generator yearly with documentation, most recent being 6/26. The septic was last pumped 10/20/25 with no issues documented (documentation also available).

  • 2 weeks on Realtyless

Property history

  • Pending sale

    Oct 27, 2026

    $309,900

    $248/sqft
  • Listed for sale

    Oct 12, 2026

    $309,900

    Up 188.0%$248/sqft
  • Sold

    Jun 2, 2016

    $107,500

    $86/sqft

Monthly payment estimate

$2,108/mo

Principal & interest
$1,690
Property tax
$325
Home insurance
$93

Down payment · $61,980

Estimate only, using local tax and insurance figures. Your actual payment depends on your lender. Starting rate: Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average, week of Oct 29.

Map showing 5272 Warrensville Rd Montoursville, PA 17754

Home values in 17754

in 2025
+1.9%
over 5 years
+33.4%

FHFA House Price Index for the ZIP code through 2025: past prices across the area, not a value for this home or a forecast.

Explore nearby cities

Deal alerts

Find the best deals

Sign up today and be the first to hear about new deals.

  • Sort homes by best deal
  • Compare asking prices to estimated values
  • Contact owners directly