Fair Deal Based on an estimated value, which may not reflect the home's current market value.

2121 Pinehurst StSarasota, FL 34231

$514,999

Est. $454,000

  • 1,752 sqft
  • 3 beds
  • 2 baths

About this home

  • Turfed playground area
  • Custom cabinetry throughout
  • Hurricane high-impact windows
  • Beautifully designed backsplash
  • Newly tiled shower
  • Cedar closet
  • Custom pantry cabinet

FOR SALE BY OWNER | SOUTH SARASOTA GEM!

3BR + Den | 2BA | 0.26 Acre | NO HOA | NO DEED RESTRICTIONS | Near Siesta Key Beach!

Custom craftsmanship, flexible living space, and a backyard made for entertaining! Welcome to 2121 Pinehurst St, a distinctive South Sarasota home offering comfort, thoughtful upgrades, generous storage, and an unbeatable location.

CUSTOM CRAFTSMANSHIP & THOUGHTFUL DETAILS

Enjoy custom cabinetry throughout, beautiful hardwood and slate flooring, and a stunning kitchen featuring marble countertops, custom cabinetry, a custom pantry cabinet, and a beautifully designed backsplash.

The spacious bedrooms offer generous closet space, including a cedar closet. The primary suite features a spacious walk-in closet and an ensuite bathroom with dual vanities and a newly tiled shower.

VALUABLE UPGRADES

New roof installed July 2025 High-end A/C unit, regularly serviced New septic drain field installed November 2022 Hurricane high-impact windows EXTRA SPACE TO LIVE, WORK & PLAY

In addition to 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, a dedicated den/playroom offers flexibility for a home office, children's playroom, media room, hobby space, or private retreat. The attached 2-car garage includes additional storage.

YOUR OWN FLORIDA BACKYARD RETREAT

Enjoy a fully fenced backyard on approximately 0.26 acres, featuring lush landscaping with native Florida plants, a turfed playground area, and a dedicated fire pit gathering space.

Approximately 400 additional square feet of concrete patio space offers the perfect opportunity to create an outdoor dining area, host weekend barbecues, or entertain family and friends.

NO HOA. NO DEED RESTRICTIONS. Enjoy greater freedom to make the most of your property without HOA fees or association rules.

AN OUTSTANDING SOUTH SARASOTA LOCATION

Located less than ¼ mile from the newly reimagined Sarasota Square Mall area, you'll enjoy convenient access to shopping, dining, and everyday essentials, including Whole Foods, Costco, and Trader Joe's.

Siesta Key Beach is approximately 3 miles away, with an estimated 10-minute drive! Enjoy beautiful Gulf Coast beaches, spectacular sunsets, restaurants, shopping, and recreation close to home.

PROPERTY HIGHLIGHTS

3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms + dedicated den/playroom Approximately 0.26-acre lot NO HOA or deed restrictions Custom cabinetry throughout Marble kitchen countertops and backsplash Hardwood and slate flooring Spacious bedrooms with generous closet space Cedar closet and primary walk-in closet Primary bathroom with dual vanity and newly tiled shower Hurricane high-impact windows New roof (July 2025) High-end, regularly serviced A/C New septic drain field (November 2022) Fully fenced backyard with native Florida landscaping Turfed playground and fire pit area Approximately 400 SF of additional concrete patio space Attached 2-car garage with additional storage Less than ¼ mile to shopping and dining Approximately 10 minutes to Siesta Key Beach YOUR NEXT CHAPTER STARTS HERE!

If you're looking for custom details, flexible living space, a beautiful backyard, and the freedom of no HOA or deed restrictions, this South Sarasota home deserves a closer look.

More space. More freedom. Custom character. An incredible location.

?? 2121 Pinehurst St, Sarasota, FL 34231

Contact the owner directly to schedule your private showing!

  • 1 week on Realtyless
  • 4 views

Property history

  • Listed for sale

    Oct 11, 2026

    $514,999

    Up 12.0%$294/sqft
  • Sold

    Dec 27, 2022

    $460,000

    Down 8.0%$263/sqft
  • Pending sale

    Nov 6, 2022

    $499,000

    $285/sqft

Monthly payment estimate

$3,530/mo

Principal & interest
$2,830
Property tax
$545
Home insurance
$154

Down payment · $103,000

Estimate only, using local tax and insurance figures. Your actual payment depends on your lender. Starting rate: Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average, week of Oct 22.

Become a lender

No mortgage partner is listed here yet. Advertise as a lender on Realtyless and connect with buyers exploring this home.

Become a Lender
Map showing 2121 Pinehurst St Sarasota, FL 34231

Home values in 34231

in 2025
-8.1%
over 5 years
+53%

FHFA House Price Index for the ZIP code through 2025: past prices across the area, not a value for this home or a forecast.

Explore nearby cities

Deal alerts

Find the best deals

Sign up today and be the first to hear about new deals.

  • Sort homes by best deal
  • Compare asking prices to estimated values
  • Contact owners directly