Good Deal Based on an estimated value, which may not reflect the home's current market value.

35 Sheep Pasture RdPort Jefferson, NY 11777

$699,999

Est. $913,400

  • 2,016 sqft
  • 4 beds
  • 3 baths

About this home

  • Spacious yard
  • Front porch
  • Central air conditioning
  • Gas heat
  • Two-car attached garage
  • Gas cooking
  • Large driveway

PRICED TO SELL — A TRUE DIAMOND IN THE ROUGH IN PORT JEFFERSON! Location, space and potential! Welcome to 35 Sheep Pasture Road, a spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial offering approximately 2,030 sq. ft. of living space on just over half an acre in the Port Jefferson School District. Annual property taxes are approximately $12,957. Built in 2005, this home is truly a diamond in the rough and is priced to sell with its updating potential in mind. With approximately 2,030 sq. ft., four bedrooms, 2.5 baths and over half an acre, this property offers exceptional space and value for the area and a wonderful opportunity for the next owner to make it their own. The main level features a huge open living and dining area, spacious kitchen, separate large den with sliding doors, half bath and laundry area. The home's solid oak hardwood floors have just been professionally refinished, and the walls and ceilings have been freshly painted, giving the home a fresh start while still leaving plenty of opportunity to personalize and update. Upstairs you'll find a large primary suite with a walk-in closet and private full bath, plus three additional generously sized bedrooms, another full bathroom and an abundance of closet and storage space throughout the home. Additional features include central air conditioning, gas heat, gas cooking, public sewer, two-car attached garage, utility basement with Bilco-door access, attic storage, large driveway, front porch and a spacious yard. LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! Enjoy being just minutes from downtown Port Jefferson Village, the LIRR train station, hospital, schools, parks, beach, shopping, restaurants and everything the Port Jefferson area has to offer. The kitchen and bathrooms offer an opportunity for cosmetic updating, allowing the next owner to choose their own finishes and create the home they want rather than paying a premium for someone else's renovations. Priced to sell and offering exceptional space, property and potential for the area. Bring your vision and don't miss the opportunity to make this Port Jefferson diamond in the rough your own! FOR SALE BY OWNER — Serious buyers and buyer's agents welcome. Private showings available by appointment.

  • 3 weeks on Realtyless
  • 5 views

Property history

  • Listed for sale

    Sep 30, 2026

    $699,999

    Down 22.0%$347/sqft
  • Listing removed

    Jun 7, 2026

    $899,000

    $446/sqft
  • Listed for sale

    May 27, 2026

    $899,000

    Up 38.0%$446/sqft

Monthly payment estimate

$5,166/mo

Principal & interest
$3,877
Property tax
$1,079
Home insurance
$210

Down payment · $140,000

Estimate only, using local tax and insurance figures. Your actual payment depends on your lender. Starting rate: Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average, week of Oct 15.

Become a lender

No mortgage partner is listed here yet. Advertise as a lender on Realtyless and connect with buyers exploring this home.

Become a Lender
Map showing 35 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, NY 11777

Home values in 11777

in 2025
+4.6%
over 5 years
+43%

FHFA House Price Index for the ZIP code through 2025: past prices across the area, not a value for this home or a forecast.

Explore nearby cities

Deal alerts

Find the best deals

Sign up today and be the first to hear about new deals.

  • Sort homes by best deal
  • Compare asking prices to estimated values
  • Contact owners directly