Middlebury, IN

16 homes for sale by owner

For Sale By Owner (FSBO) Homes in Middlebury, IN: 16 homes found

  • 6395 N 725 W - Property Image
    Good Deal
    For sale by owner

    $435,000

    • 4 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1,964 sqft

    6395 N 725 W · Shipshewana, IN

  • 7500 S 700 W - Property Image
    Good Deal
    For sale by owner

    $400,000

    • 3 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 2,028 sqft

    7500 S 700 W · Topeka, IN

  • 1200 Taylor Dr - Property Image
    Fair Price
    For sale by owner

    $387,000

    • 4 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 2,896 sqft

    1200 Taylor Dr · Shipshewana, IN

  • 7460 S 700 W - Property Image
    Good Deal
    For sale by owner

    $240,000

    • 3 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1,152 sqft

    7460 S 700 W · Topeka, IN

  • 225 N 100 W - Property Image
    Good Deal
    For sale by owner

    $359,000

    • 5 bd
    • 3 ba
    • 3,792 sqft

    225 N 100 W · Lagrange, IN

  • 602 S Martin St - Property Image
    Good Deal
    For sale by owner

    $209,000

    • 4 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 2,271 sqft

    602 S Martin St · Ligonier, IN

  • 2301 Aurora Ave - Property Image
    Good Deal
    For sale by owner

    $269,900

    • 5 bd
    • 3.5 ba
    • 3,246 sqft

    2301 Aurora Ave · Elkhart, IN

  • 11795 W State Road 120 - Property Image
    Good Deal
    For sale by owner

    $329,000

    • 3 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 2,084 sqft

    11795 W State Road 120 · Middlebury, IN

  • 63115 County Road 31 - Property Image
    Fair Price
    For sale by owner

    $489,000

    • 4 bd
    • 3 ba
    • 2,580 sqft

    63115 County Road 31 · Goshen, IN

  • 57350 County Road 19 - Property Image
    Good Deal
    For sale by owner

    $430,000

    • 5 bd
    • 4 ba
    • 2,770 sqft

    57350 County Road 19 · Goshen, IN

  • 22108 County Road 26 - Property Image
    Above Estimate
    For sale by owner

    $424,900

    • 4 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 2,112 sqft

    22108 County Road 26 · Goshen, IN

  • 814 Wayne St - Property Image
    Above Estimate
    For sale by owner

    $289,000

    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 1,462 sqft

    814 Wayne St · Middlebury, IN

  • 14515 County Road 34 - Property Image
    Above Estimate
    For sale by owner

    $412,000

    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 1,792 sqft

    14515 County Road 34 · Goshen, IN

  • 1225 Southbrooke - Property Image
    Above Estimate
    For sale by owner

    $449,000

    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1,970 sqft

    1225 Southbrooke · Shipshewana, IN

  • 59636 County Road 19 - Property Image
    Above Estimate
    For sale by owner

    $600,000

    • 4 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 2,434 sqft

    59636 County Road 19 · Goshen, IN

  • 19178 County Road 2 - Property Image
    For sale by owner

    $2,500,000

    • 3 bd
    • 4 ba
    • 4,950 sqft

    19178 County Road 2 · Bristol, IN

You've reached the end

That's all 16 homes in Middlebury, IN

Widen the area, or try a nearby city.

Get new deals by email

Sign up and we'll email you new good deals, fair prices and price drops that match your searches.

Sign up for deal emails

Selling a home in Middlebury, IN? Look up yours for a free estimate

Loading map